Two Crossed Swords Hint 3

First Mate McGee - 1
Peg Legged Peggy - 3
Planky Peter - 5  
One Eye Willie -7 
Captain Ginger Beard - 9

STOP BEFORE YOU GO TO THE ANSWER: This is a tricky lock.  If you think you have the correct answer, but the lock is not opening, realign the numbers again, PERFECTLY between the two arrows and give it a FIRM tug to open the lock. If it's not opening, then you can check the answer.